About Us

Known for our oversized pizza slices and most recently recognized for “Best Sauce” in the Hudson Valley, Gappy’s has become the go-to pizza restaurant for locals and travelers alike. Owner, George Papazian opened the doors of Gappy’s Pizza in January 2002.

With our dedicated kitchen staff, Gappy’s has been serving up quality food at affordable prices for over a decade. This is the place, “where you’re treated like family!” The super-friendly staff welcomes you and yours to have a relaxed and casual dining experience. After just a few visits, we’ll know your favorite beverage and how you like your burger cooked. We offer a full menu from our Margherita Pizza to the tasty, freshly-made Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Wings and Lasagna (just to name a few.) We offer beer, wine, desserts and extended weekend hours to accommodate travelers, late night workers and late night cravings…

We are conveniently located off I-84, exit 17 in Lake Carmel and invite you to stop by and “Get Happy at Gappy’s!”

Our Menus


Come dine with us!

View Menu


Pick your food up yourself!

View Menu

A perfect ending.

View Menu

Let us cater your event!

View Menu

Our Promise

Family Owned, Family Operated, Family Oriented.

At Gappy's we know you have many choices in where you dine. That's why our staff is dedicated to ensuring that your family's dining experience with us is the most welcoming and satisfying. From the cleanliness of our facility, to the quality and taste of our food, we promise to maintain the highest standards and hope to make you and your family regular guests. If you're not completely satisfied with your experience at Gappy's please use the form below to get in touch with us so we can make things right.



Gappy's Pizza updated their profile picture. ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Our Menu
In house dining, take out, desserts, and catering.
These are also available on our updated website. gappyspizza.com
... See MoreSee Less

Our in-house menu for dining in. Our take-out menu for taking out. Our dessert menu. Our catering menu.

View on Facebook

Some photos of our dining room decorated for the holidays.
Decorating credit to Jean!
... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Yummy food! Watch short video below. Enjoy!
Photo credits to Laura G!

Check out this movie on Magisto: Gappy's
... See MoreSee Less

Created using Magisto. Share your story using the free video editing app that transforms your photos and videos with the swipe of your finger. Available for Android and iOS.

View on Facebook

Hiring! We are looking for an experienced pizza maker. Stop by and fill out an application. ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Find Us!

Directions and Contact Info

1323 New York 52 Carmel, NY
(845) 878-0800
Use Form Below For Email


Monday - Thursday 11:00am - 10:00pm
Friday & Saturday 11:00am - 2:00am
Sunday 12 noon - 9:00pm

Contact Us

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)


Your Message